DEPA for AI Training should be an instrument for boositng Indigenous AI models

 

DEPA for AI training, a document released for discussion by MeitY has been developed with the assistance of iSPIRT.

A detailed discussion on the document will be held at IDPS 2026 both at Bangalore on November 21, 2026 and at Hyderabad on November 28 2026.

Further the delegates can particiapte in a survey and express their views on different aspects of the framework.

The detailed online questionnaire will be made available after the event.

One of the key questions on which the survey is being conducted  include

“Should access to DEPA-AIT be limited to Indian-owned and Indian-controlled entities? “

It is well known that India by virtue of its population and its high level of digital activity is a gold mine of information for the AI Model training activity. As a result all the global AI players eye on the Indian data and monetizing it through various means.

The DPDPA which is becoming effective from 13th May 2027 has been putting a hurdle on the “Personal Data Collection” exercise of the AI model trainers since questions are being asked about whether the “Permission to use personal data for a service” can automatically be considered as a permission with which a data fiduciary may share the data with a AI model trainer. Pareticularly when some of the data fiduciaries are Banks and Hospitals, they are “Signfiicant Data Fiduciaries” and are subject to DPIA and annudal data audit.

The DEPA-AIT cleverly builds an argument to legally by-pass DPDPA restrictions.

The document makes a reference to DEPA current architecture where a Consent manager in the mould of an account aggregator can obtain consent of the data principal, (which is called “DEPA Inference”, and states,

“While DEPA Inference  manages the consented flow of individual data for inferencing (using an existing model), it isn’t designed to handle the privacy-preserving aggregation of bulk, de-identified data needed to build the AI models in the first place. The core issues are different.”

The discussion is then  diverted to the security and “Anonymization” of data and concludes “individual consent via DEPA Inference is impractical at this scale and doesn’t solve the institutional risk problem.”

Further it states:

” DEPA Inference addresses consented sharing for individual benefit in specific transactions; it doesn’t provide the framework for secure, privacy-preserving pooling of aggregate data required for building powerful AI models. This necessitates DEPA for AI Training (and Data Sharing for AI Training Framework), a new layer designed specifically to unlock the value of aggregate data for AI training while upholding privacy and security through advanced technologies and governance mechanisms.”

“Without access to diverse, large-scale datasets, Indian startups, researchers, and even established companies outside the dominant tech giants would struggle to develop cutting-edge AI solutions tailored to local needs.”

The Training Data Providers under the scheme are the Data Fiduciaries who hold the Rs 850 crore liability hanging on their head and a new intermediary called “Data Collabs” is suggested as a vehicle to transport the data to the Model owners who are called the Training Data Consumers. Data Collabs are business centric, sector specific and conceptualized to be commercial players. The framework however does not call them “Data Brokers”.

The document also makes a comment

“AI is a complex, and rapidly evolving technology. Static, top-down regulations, enforced through manual screening or audits are ill-suited to the pace of this digital technology. “

In our considered view, the scheme DEPA for AI Training is designed to bypass DPDPA as a law diluting the permission control of the data principals to be informed and to be able to control the secondary processing of personal Data.

This will expose the data fiduciaries inclduing hospitals, Banks and the Government departments  to the risk of penalties under DPDPA. The benefit on the other hand flows to the AI model developers who hold no DPDPA risks.

Since the use of the platrorm is not restricted to Indigenous model developers, the sovereign data is being handed over on a platter to the foreign AI players and this indicates a serious flaw in the logic whether it was intended or not.

If a tweaking of the law is required, it should be only to benefit the Indian start ups and Indian model developers and hence the access to the platform should have been strictly restricted to local companies with a fit and proper criteria. The Data Collabs should be considered as Data Fiduciaries themselves, completly insulating the Data Fiduciaries like hospitals and banks from the liabilities arising out of unauthorized use of personal data for AI model training.

I wish an appropriate Court takes a look at the model suo moto and give its views. Alternatively it should be taken to the Courts for opinion as a PIL case.

This is my personal view and others are free to differ.

iSPIRT which is the brain behind this scheme has been invited to the IDPS 2026 and we hope they attend and defend the framework against the above views.

Naavi

Posted in Privacy | Leave a comment

IDPS 2026-Hyderabad

Registrations for IDPS Bangalore is coming to a close. Rush to check if there are any vacant seats. In the meantime, Registrartions for Hyderabad event on 28th November 2026, at Radisson Hotel, Hitec City is now open.

Information  link is here.

Registration link is here

 

Contact fdppi for more details.

In case iLet Link for registratation is not working, contact fdppi4privacy @gmail.com

Naavi

Posted in Privacy | Leave a comment

Battery of speakers at IDPS 2026 in Bangalore

November 21, 2026 at Fairfield Marriott, IDPS 2026 at Bangalore is all set to bring a valuable discussion on several aspects of DPDPA. Several eminent speakers are congregating to bring their vast experience and expertise to the audience.

The main theme of the seminar is “Data Protection and AI, Accountability by Audit”. There will be discussions on the impact of AI on DPDPA impelementation and how accountability can be established through Data Audit.

FDPPI being the pioneer in promoting the concept of “Independent Data Auditors” through a specialized professional enity , Association of Independent Data Auditors and the AIGSI the AI Governance standard of India, there should be several discussions on the recent developments including the Consent Manager registration, AI Audit framework by CERT In, DEPA for AI-Training by iSPIRT, as well as the AI Agentic accountability discussion paper released by DSCI.

Donot miss this opportunity to take part in the premium knowledge based seminar on Data Protection which values content more than fanfare.

Justice Sri V Srishanand Sri Ramesh Behera Naavi

Three distinct documents will be discussed in some detail. The AI Governance Standard of India along with how it compares with the CERT In AI audit framework, and DSCI discussion paper on AGentic AI accountability , DGPSI Compliance Manual for Bank Branches and Data Empoerment and Protection Architecture (DEPA) for AI training.

A survey of the professionals would also be taken for the DEPA-AIT so that professionals can answer over 30 questions which can later be consolidated and forwarded to MeitY.

It is the endeavour of FDPPI to make every minute of your time at the Conference valuable and every rupee you pay as delegate fee is returned back in terms of the “Value of Data Transfer” that occurs in the 9.00 am to 5.00 pm event.

We request that all delegates are there in their seats by 8.45 so that we can shart the program sharp at 9.00 am.

Donot regret if you by missing out on this wonderful opportunity to interact with the best in the industry.

Naavi

 

Posted in Privacy | Leave a comment

Heros of IDPS 2026

IDPS 2026 as its six predecessors indicate is a conference where the essence is transfer of valuable knowledge. Each of the 6 hours of the day (November 21, 2026) at Fairfield, Marriott, Rajaji Nagar will present discussions and thoughts which you would reflect over many days and which will enrich your understanding of DPDPA, AI, Accountability and other topics meant for discussion.

Inauguration at 9.00 am

Honourable Justice Sri V Srishananda Sri Ramesh Chandra Behera

The program will be inaugurated by honourable Justice Sri V Srishananda.

Be there sharp at 9.00 am to listen to the words of wisdom by the honourable JusticeSri V Srishananda, sitting judge of Karnataka High Court and Sri Ramesh Behera, Chairman of Madhya Pradesh Gramin Bank.

Apart from the individuals who will share their expert views and experience to the audience, there will be three other heros namely the three publications which will be made available to the delegates and briefly discussed during the event.

AIGSI presents both the framework presented by FDPPI along with the recent CERT In guidelines on AI audit and the DSCI discussion paper on AI accountability. The DGPSI Compliance manual is a draft manual meant for Bank Branches to comply with DPDPA and contribute to the aggregate compliance of the Bank. The DEPA for AI Training is a discussion paper which presents the recent handbook released by MeitY on a framework for sharing of data for AI Training. This will be presented for discussion and a survey of the feedback.

Donot miss an opportunity to be exposed to these discussions at Bangalore on November 21st and again in Hyderabad on November 28 (Hotel Radisson, HITECH City).

Participate and contribute to the development of thoughts on DPDPA.

 

Naavi

Posted in Privacy | Leave a comment

DPB website is now open

We are happy to note that DPB website has become active before the end of the day. We had posted in the morning that MeitY has missed the milestone.

It is interesting that the milestone has been reached before the end of the day.

Our Good wishes to the Ministry.

While www.dpbi.gov.in appears to be the official version of the website, there exists another site www.dpbi.in which is maintained by a private citizen Mr P Krishna, whose registrant details have been redacted on the NIXI website.

(P.S: Since this website is not a personal information website, redacting the registrant information is a mis applications of the principles of Right to Privacy.)

This site appears as follows:

It has a disclaimer that this is  a:

Public awareness website by Krishna P · info@dpbi.in : Not a government website · Not legal advice · No data collected 
It is an independent citizen effort. It has no affiliation with the Government of India, the Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology, or the Data Protection Board of India, and it does not speak for them.

We recall that NIXI had earlier issued a take over notice on Naavi for the domain name www.dpdpa.in. (Notice subsequently was countered). Now the website www.dpb.in is a site which could be easily confused with www.dpbi.in. This is a clear “Confusingly similar website”. The site is well designed but the disclaimer needs to be more prominent. A look-alike disclaimer is also required on the webstite www.dpbi.in.

It would be interesting to see what action NIXI would take on this domain.

Naavi

P.S: Naavi had earlier wrongly projected www.dpbi.in as the site of Data Protection Board of India. We sincerely apologize for the same.

Posted in Privacy | Leave a comment

PIB flouts the basic DPDPA Principle

Enclosed is a screen shot of the page today about the press conference conducted by MeitY for release of DEPA framework for AI Training.

https://www.pib.gov.in/PressReleaseIframePage.aspx?PRID=2330756&reg=48&lang=2

As one can notice, in the bottom there is a notice in Hindi and the Google translation indicates that it is a cookie notice.

PIB is said to be a national resource and the website is meant for viewing by everybody in India including those who are down south and cannot understand Hindi. It is clearly an attempt to impose Hindi through the website . DPDPA expects that such notices should be available in 22 languages.

We need an explanation from PIB why they are providing this legal notice only in Hindi even though the access is from outside the Hindi region.

Naavi

Posted in Privacy | Leave a comment